Tuesday, July 15, 2014

Comparing Air Games

My local gaming group prefers the Check Your Six aircraft rules. They work well and provide a great game. I have enjoyed the TFL Bag the Hun rules. They also are fun and provide a good game. What I have never done is play the two side by side. I thought it would make an interesting comparison.

I started with just a simple scenario, a pair of Bf109es and a pair of Hawker Hurricanes. Both sides are regular pilots with nothing extra. The first run through was with Bag the Hun. It took four short turns. The first turn had the aircraft close. The second turn had aircraft turn and the card system ended up with the British Hurricanes in a vulnerable position. The third turn gave the initial cards to the German's favor and the first of the British Hurricanes exploded in the air. The remaining British aircraft attempted to run for it. The fourth and final turn had the Germans on the tail of the final British aircraft which netted in the British pilot being killed.

The result was it proved to be an excellent solo play system that resolved combat quickly and was deadly. Maneuvering to contact was easy and allowed to get to grips with the enemy.

The second game reset the pieces and Check Your 6 was given a roll out. This was a different kettle of fish. I like the preset turn determination. But doing this is not as easy for solo play in my opinion. It also took longer for the aircraft to come to grips. For a multi-player game, this is actually not a problem at all. The firing mechanism as slightly more cumbersome but mostly because I am less familiar with it than with Bag the Hun. In the end, I had one exploded Hurricane and one that was able to run for his life.

This was also a good and plausible result. And it was a fun game. I really enjoyed both of these rules. For solo play, I think I will stick with Bag the Hun. For multi-player games, I will probably keep going with CY6.

4 comments:

  1. Thanks for that have been tempted to do some solo air wars stuff and was debating what rules to use

    ReplyDelete
  2. Playing the same scenario over different rulesets is an excellent method to compare and contrast these differences. Looks like your trials produced useful results!

    My air war gaming has been confined to WWI with Canvas Eagles and Watch Your Six.

    ReplyDelete
  3. An interesting comparison. I like CY6, it does seem to take time to close but once the fight begins!!!

    ReplyDelete
  4. BtH does work best for solo play, but we settled on Cy6 because we like the simultaneous element. And plenty of chrome that doesn't bog the system down. Cy6 really comes into its best when you get 4 players (or more).

    ReplyDelete